Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Introduction Clinical placements may support transversal competencies in health professions education, but evidence across placement periods remains mixed. Objective To compare empathy, assertiveness, resilience, and vocation of care between two anonymous repeated cross-sectional waves of Nursing and Physical Therapy students surveyed before and after the clinical placement period, and to integrate student self-reports with a complementary group-level perspective from clinical tutors. Methods This mixed-methods study used repeated cross-sectional waves. The analysis included 131 questionnaires (T0, n = 75; T1, n = 56). Anonymous collection prevented individual matching; observations were analyzed as independent. Measures included the Interpersonal Reactivity Index, Rathus Assertiveness Schedule, CD-RISC-10, Vocation of Human Care Scale, and social desirability at T0. Fifty-three clinical tutors provided five ratings and open-ended responses. Models adjusted for degree programme, gender, prior experience, and age. Qualitative responses underwent qualitative content analysis with a combined deductive-inductive approach. Results No adjusted T0–T1 differences occurred in the seven student outcomes; all wave effects remained non-significant after Holm correction (adjusted p ≥ .735). Nursing students scored higher in fantasy and assertiveness, and women in empathic concern; these were secondary findings. Social desirability was independently associated with perspective taking, resilience, and vocation of care at T0. Correlation patterns were consistent across waves. Tutor ratings were favorable and did not differ by program. Qualitative findings identified time pressure, insecurity, limited initiative, and theory–practice integration as recurring challenges. Conclusions No robust group-level differences were detected between waves. Because participants could not be matched, the findings do not demonstrate intraindividual stability. Mixed-methods integration showed that favorable perceptions coexist with educational needs in communication, clinical reasoning, reflection, and supervised progressive responsibility.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Báez‐Suárez et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: