Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Microalloy binary and complex particles play a fundamental role in controlling microstructures and properties throughout steelmaking processes. Their stability is described by solubility products; however, the relationships reported in the literature exhibit considerable variability among different authors and were established using different experimental and thermodynamic techniques. This review critically assesses the development and applicability of solubility products for microalloy precipitates in ferrite and austenite. More than 90 literature-reported solubility products were compiled and classified according to precipitate type, matrix phase in which they were obtained and methodology. Specific attention was directed towards NbC and TiC, to which published relationships were quantitatively compared. A regression analysis was used to derive global solubility products for ferrite and austenite. The assessment reveals considerable scatter in the reported relationships and a marked imbalance between matrix phases, with most studies focusing on austenite. Furthermore, it was also established that ferritic solubility products were obtained predominantly with thermodynamic calculations, as no experimental work has been reported in the literature. Experimental evidence under ferrite–austenite coexistence is particularly limited. Finally, industrial examples are provided to demonstrate that equilibrium solubility alone cannot describe the microalloying state developed during thermomechanical processing, where precipitation and dissolution kinetics are critical. Improved experimental validation, particularly in ferrite and the intercritical region, is therefore required to strengthen the application of solubility products to industrial steel design.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Pisano et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: