Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Semiarid conditions, aeolian disturbance, and long-term cultivation have progressively weakened soil structure and nutrient-retention capacity in Calciustoll croplands of western Jilin Province. Although organic amendments improve soil quality, their comparative benefits after consecutive applications remain unclear. A two-year field experiment (2024–2025) compared four treatments: conventional compound fertilizer (CK), CK co-applied with cattle manure (CM) or granular organic fertilizer (GOF), and a biochar-based compound fertilizer (CBF) replacing CK. Soil physicochemical properties were assessed in both years, whereas enzyme activities and microbial communities were characterized in 2025. Fertility enhancement was evaluated using the soil quality index (SQI) and soil microbial index (SMI). All three amendments improved the Calciustoll to varying degrees. In the 0–20-cm layer, SQI peaked under CM in 2024 and CBF in 2025. SQI under CBF significantly exceeded that under CK by 76.96%, whereas SMI was significantly higher than that under every other treatment in both layers. CM promoted soil organic matter and nitrogen accumulation and increased C-related hydrolytic enzyme activities and urease activity, whereas CBF exhibited higher acid phosphatase activity. Exploratory pooled Spearman analyses suggested positive associations among SMI, SQI, and several enzyme activities; however, these relationships were not retained after accounting for treatment, soil depth, block, and plot-level pairing. Overall, CM more strongly promoted soil organic matter and nitrogen accumulation, whereas CBF produced broader SQI and SMI improvements after two years.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bao et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: