Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A salaried employee's income-tax return looks simple from the outside. Most of the figures arrive already printed on Form 16, and much of the rest is pre-filled on the e-filing portal. What a practice actually does for such a client is less visible: it checks whether each exemption the client wants to claim is backed by evidence, values any benefit in kind correctly, compares the client's own statement of income with what employers and banks have reported, and works out which of the two tax regimes leaves the client with less tax. This paper looks at that routine at E-Arth Accounts Finance & Management Consultants (E-Arth AFMC), Pune, where I worked as an on-the-job trainee between 1 June and 31 July 2026 on the preparation and filing of ITR-1 returns for Assessment Year 2026-27, with particular attention to House Rent Allowance (HRA) and the rent-free accommodation (RFA) perquisite. The study is descriptive and exploratory. Client data is confidential, so the paper uses no client names, PANs or individual figures beyond one anonymised and rounded salary. It works with the eleven steps of the firm's ITR-1 workflow, the documents verified, the recurring exceptions met in about fifteen returns, and four worked tax computations under both regimes. Seven of the eleven steps (63.6 per cent) drew directly on documents supplied by the client. In the four computations the new regime gave the lower tax in three; of the three cases with an HRA claim, the old regime was cheaper in only one, and that advantage of ₹9,100 would disappear if about ₹29,200 of claimed relief could not be supported. Of five recurring exception types, two concerned the evidence behind an HRA claim, two were income or tax figures that the client's account and the Department's records did not agree on, and one arose from the way an employer labelled salary components. The paper argues that the regime decision and the exemption claim cannot be separated, because an exemption that cannot be evidenced is worth nothing in either regime. Collecting rent proof and the landlord's PAN at intake, and computing both regimes for every client, are the most economical improvements open to a practice of this size. None of the measures proposed needs new software.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Devle et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: