Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background Since 2016 Uzbekistan has expanded higher education rapidly, and the 2023 Constitution (Article 51) now states that higher education institutions (HEIs) enjoy academic freedom, self-governance and freedom of research and teaching “in accordance with law”. Much of the governance of universities, however, is still set by presidential and governmental acts rather than by statute. Purpose The article asks how far the legal framework in force in September 2026 gives operational effect to Article 51 in four areas: leadership selection, supervisory boards, the governance of academic chairs and faculty academic freedom, and degree-granting authority. Methods A qualitative doctrinal design is combined with a historical-institutionalist framework. A corpus of 15 Uzbek normative acts (2006–2026), selected by explicit criteria, is analysed with a four-step protocol for identifying conflicts between norms, with Tashkent State University of Law (TSUL) as an embedded case. Findings are tested against external indicators and a functional comparison with Germany, England and the Russian Federation. Results Article 51 has no statutory implementing framework: the Law on Education neither defines academic freedom nor institutional autonomy. Key governance rules are made and remade by executive acts. The clearest example is rector appointment: the Law on Education vests it in the Cabinet of Ministers, whereas a 2026 presidential decree transfers it to the Minister from 1 September 2026 and removes the supervisory-board appointment route that had applied to financially autonomous HEIs since 2023. The Soviet-derived chair structure remains, although a 2025 decree introduces elected academic leadership at TSUL. A May 2026 decree abolishes central confirmation of each scientific degree from 2027 but gives the attestation body powers to rate councils and to annul their decisions. Contribution We propose the concept of “autonomy by delegation”: autonomy that is granted, recalibrated and withdrawn through sub-statutory executive acts and is therefore revocable. The article offers a replicable conflict-mapping protocol and ranked, statute-centred reform recommendations relevant to Uzbekistan and other Central Asian systems.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ergashev et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: