Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Rural places are often depicted as “left behind” regions in the United States, facing ongoing economic distress and population decline. While many rural places reflect this archetype, others do not. Some rural places, especially those endowed with natural amenities or closer to metropolitan areas, have seen considerable recent growth. To unpack the heterogeneity across rural places in the United States and the challenges these communities face, we ask rural practitioners: (1) what common challenges are rural places and populations facing due to population change? and (2) how do these challenges vary according to whether rural places are experiencing population growth or decline? To answer these questions, we draw on data from a series of national listening sessions with over 80 rural development practitioners conducted in 2024. We find that both growing and declining rural places are experiencing similar challenges related to constrained access to local goods and services, particularly health care, dependent care, and housing. Yet the mechanisms underlying these challenges and the expressions of them vary. Overall, this paper uses the perspectives of rural development practitioners to highlight areas of needed research related to rural population change. The paper also argues that future research should study growing and declining rural communities in tandem rather than as separate phenomena to advance theory and practice concerning the impacts of population change.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kelly et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: