Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Featuring independent artistic and architectural organizations, this Roundtable uses Earthmoving (see Earthmoving: Extractivism, War, and Visuality in Northern Kurdistan , Çaylı 2025) as a springboard to explore visual culture’s role in withstanding environments shaped by coloniality in contexts without the formal status of a colony. It does so across three geographies with interconnected histories of territorial erasure, demographic engineering, racialization, and extractive governance: Macedonias, Kurdistans, and Armenias. Today extractivism – the environmental hallmark of coloniality and its centrality to racial patriarchal capitalism – operates increasingly by mobilizing environmental sensibilities rather than simply denying ecological harm, and visuality is central to this mobilization. If this implicates visual culture and knowledge in the ways territories, landscapes, and populations are rendered legible, governable, and extractable, it also renders this cultural and epistemic realm as a foremost arena for questioning extractivism. How do collectives organizing through visual culture in Macedonias, Kurdistans, and Armenias grapple with extractivism in contexts of statusless coloniality? This Roundtable explores this question by moving away from considering visual culture as a straightforward arena of heroic resistance. It turns instead to the fraught everyday labour of sustaining spaces amid uneven funding and surveillance, urban erasure and environmental decay, infrastructural collapse, precarious and uncompensated work, and unequal conditions of translocal exchange. Gathering, archiving, documenting, repairing, and maintaining emerge as visual cultural practices that negotiate rather than entirely stand outside extractive structures. If clean ideological victories or seamless solidarities are difficult to attain, differently situated struggles within shared historical and systemic binds nevertheless point towards important political possibilities: forms of painstaking and daily collective practice that sense and make sense of environments of statuslessness otherwise.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Çaylı et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: