Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This 8-week mixed-methods study examined how English as a foreign language (EFL) learners navigate, interpret, and appropriate ChatGPT-generated and teacher-delivered feedback across sequential instructional phases, and what motivational and writing consequences this navigation produces. Using a within-subjects design, 24 intermediate university-level EFL learners completed 5 genre-based paragraph tasks across 3 feedback phases: baseline (no feedback), ChatGPT-only (GPT-4o mini), and blended (ChatGPT combined with teacher mediation). Data comprised rubric-based writing scores, phase-specific surveys, and focus-group interviews analyzed through the AI-Mediated Writing (AIM-W) framework. Qualitative findings revealed a developmental arc in feedback literacy: from prompt-bounded experimentation in Phase 2, through layered scaffolding recognition and selective agency, to ethical calibration of AI use in Phase 3. Motivational trajectories followed self-determination theory predictions: autonomy and competence dominated during ChatGPT-only interaction, while teacher mediation reintroduced relatedness, the missing motivational dimension, and unexpectedly strengthened trust in AI-generated feedback itself. Writing performance patterns showed micro-level stability across phases despite escalating genre demands, and macro-level gains under blended feedback, though these are reported cautiously given that genre complexity co-varied with feedback phase, constituting a design limitation that precludes causal attribution. The study contributes an empirically grounded account of how feedback literacy develops in multisource AI feedback settings, with specific implications for prompt-literacy instruction, feedback sequencing, and the pedagogical conditions under which AI-generated feedback can be responsibly integrated into EFL writing classrooms.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Harun ÇİFTCİ (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: