Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Standard multilayer perceptrons (MLPs) employed in physics-informed neural networks (PINNs) suffer from spectral bias—the systematic inability to learn high-frequency components in multi-frequency structural response signals. Recently, Kolmogorov–Arnold Networks (KANs) with learnable edge activations have been proposed as alternatives that could inherently mitigate this limitation. This study presents a rigorous, parameter-matched (~16,400 parameters per model) comparison of four neural architectures—Fourier-enhanced KAN (FPIKAN), Fourier-MLP, plain MLP, and standalone KAN—across four canonical nonlinear dynamics benchmarks: the Bouc–Wen hysteretic oscillator, the Duffing oscillator with cubic stiffness, the forced Van der Pol oscillator, and a three-degree-of-freedom shear building. A systematic 2 × 2 factorial ablation study isolates the individual contributions of (i) Fourier feature encoding and (ii) backbone architecture choice. Results demonstrate unambiguously that Fourier feature encoding is the dominant factor, reducing relative L2 errors by 98.6–100% when applied to MLP across all benchmarks. Fourier-MLP achieves the lowest error in all four benchmarks (L2 = 0.014, with L2 < 10-3 for Duffing and Van der Pol). Without Fourier encoding, KAN outperforms MLP by up to 3.5× (Van der Pol: L2 = 0.164 vs. 0.574) due to its learnable Chebyshev activations acting as implicit spectral decomposers. Paradoxically, adding Fourier encoding to KAN degrades performance in two benchmarks (Duffing: -201.7%; Van der Pol: -9.0%), and FPIKAN consistently underperforms Fourier-MLP. Analysis of gradient norms through Chebyshev polynomial layers reveals oscillatory gradient magnitudes incompatible with the smooth optimization landscape required by second-order physics residual terms. These findings provide critical, experimentally validated guidance for selecting neural architectures in computational structural dynamics.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Salih Berkan Aydemir (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: