Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Carbon capture and utilisation in concrete is projected to contribute substantially to decarbonisation, yet few routes have progressed beyond demonstration stage. This review argues that the commercialisation gap persists because CO2 uptake is treated as the primary measure of success, though it indicates little about overall viability, and no means exists of comparing pathways on a common basis. Such a comparison must capture four criteria, spanning material selection, the sequestration process, application performance and deployment feasibility. These criteria are interdependent and frequently in tension, so optimising one can worsen another. This, therefore, requires a multi-criteria decision-making framework, which this review develops through a structured narrative assessment of each criterion in turn. Each criterion is framed as a question. Material selection asks whether uptake capacity translates into meaningful carbon reduction across materials that differ in binding mechanism, property loss and available scale. The sequestration process asks whether upstream capture, uptake and material modification emit more than they bind. Application performance asks whether the material remains suitable for its intended use after uptake. Deployment feasibility asks where sequestration creates value rather than imposing a penalty, and how pathway and application should be matched. The four criteria, and the sub-criteria found to govern each, are combined into a single index that scores and ranks pathways. Applied to already commercialised routes, it shows that commercialised pathways score moderately across all four criteria and exceptionally on none. This indicates that commercialisation requires fair performance across every criterion considered here rather than excellence in any one.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rajendran et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: