Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Research on conceptual change has long emphasized the role of cognitive conflict, yet externally presented conceptual inconsistencies do not always trigger a state of cognitive conflict in learners. Metacognitive monitoring has been proposed as a potential key mechanism in this transformation process. However, existing evidence remains inconclusive as to whether metacognitive monitoring merely co-occurs with higher levels of conceptual understanding or actually predicts subsequent growth in conceptual understanding. Given the inherent difficulty of directly observing conceptual change, the present study employed a three-wave longitudinal design, using longitudinal changes in conceptual understanding as an indirect indicator of conceptual change, to investigate the dynamic interplay between metacognitive monitoring and conceptual understanding in the context of learning Newtonian mechanics. The sample comprised 691 high school students, and all measurements were embedded within regular instructional units. Metacognitive monitoring was assessed using task-embedded confidence judgments, decomposed into absolute calibration error and resolution. Conceptual understanding was quantified by rasch ability estimates derived from a half-length version of the force concept inventory. Cross-lagged panel models revealed dimension-specific longitudinal patterns for the two monitoring measures. Greater absolute calibration error was associated with lower subsequent conceptual understanding across both adjacent intervals, while higher resolution was associated with higher subsequent conceptual understanding across both intervals. The reverse paths from conceptual understanding to later monitoring varied across dimensions and intervals. Profile analyses further showed differences in subsequent conceptual understanding across monitoring configurations defined at T1. Together, these findings indicate that calibration and resolution capture distinguishable aspects of metacognitive monitoring that are prospectively associated with conceptual understanding during secondary-school mechanics learning.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yu et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: