Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Research on commoning is expanding, but there is no unifying definition or conceptual framework. Numerous definitions and narratives of what commoning is or could be are observable across research fields and empirical contexts. How is commoning scholarship different or similar to literature on the commons? In this article, we systematically review the literature on commoning across all academic fields and topics. We examine 637 peer-reviewed articles that explicitly use the term and analyze the heterogeneity of definitions, narratives, and contexts associated with the concept. We identify five core commoning narratives, each represented by distinctive terminologies and phrases of how the term is defined in the literature. The five narratives are: (1) governance, (2) relationships, (3) normative goals, (4) economy, and (5) politics. Most definitions of commoning in the literature contain elements of multiple narratives. The degree to which the different narratives of commoning extend or significantly differ from concepts of the commons is also mixed. Governance narratives, for example, tend to position commoning as an extension of the social processes for governing commons, whereas the economic and political narratives tend to frame commoning as an oppositional form of social movements towards alternative futures, not necessarily related to traditional conceptions of the commons. We attempt to understand these narratives with both quantitative and qualitative analyses to examine a range of thematic interpretations of the literature from rethinking social organization or emphasizing power and politics to embracing alternative relational ethics. In doing so, we provide examples of selected empirical studies that align with each of the five narratives, and discuss the concept’s pluralism and potential future directions. This includes how commoning differs from commons and collective action theory in its disciplinary origins and normative orientation, as well as its actionable practice-based elements. Furthermore, we interpret the observed trends as the beginning of a turn in the research paradigm on social groups, collective action, and collaboration in society. This may also be associated with a stronger normative orientation of social change research for sustainability and transformation (i.e., to produce system, target, and transformative knowledge).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Partelow et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: