Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Purpose Innovation processes, their antecedents and their outcomes are difficult to grasp without situated, in-depth inquiry, for which qualitative methods are particularly well suited. Yet persistent misunderstandings about qualitative design sustain an inertial hesitance among authors, reviewers and editors about the rigour, quality and usefulness of qualitative research. We map the critical design decisions and offer a path toward useful, auditable qualitative research, without adjudicating the paradigmatic debates. Design/methodology/approach Drawing on a purposive review of the meta-methodological literature in business and management, including agenda-setting articles, editorials, design typologies and canonical handbooks, we organise the corpus by the design decisions that qualitative researchers need to take and to report explicitly. Findings We establish the distinctive usefulness of qualitative inquiry for innovation research, identify 15 critical design decisions with their options and our recommendations and compile an inventory of the misconceptions and fatal flaws attributed to qualitative research. The decisions and the flaws are matched one to one. Seven decisions carry particular weight in innovation settings analysed by qualitative research. Research limitations/implications The review is purposive rather than systematic. The paradigmatic tensions within qualitative research are acknowledged rather than resolved. We welcome further specification of the critical design decisions within particular paradigms. Practical implications Authors may use the set to design and justify a configuration of choices. Reviewers may use the matched flaws to audit that configuration. The pairing yields an audit trail whenever qualitative research is designed or assessed. Originality/value We offer a decision-point map that abstracts from the paradigm wars and couples each design choice to the flaw that the choice is intended to avert, reframing rigour as the defensible alignment of choices rather than conformity to a template.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Czakon et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: