Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Decision-making is classically depicted as a deliberative, internal calculation conducted by a centralized nervous system selecting among pre-packaged alternatives under uncertainty. Heavily influenced by this cerebrocentric baseline, mainstream plant physiology has systematically relegated vegetative behavior to hardwired tropisms and passive stimulus-response cascades. Moreover, validating genuine choice has historically relied on rigid counterfactual testing, demanding proof that an organism could have acted otherwise under identical physical conditions. Here, we develop an embodied biosemiotic and cognitive framework to demonstrate that such counterfactual requirements represent an epistemological trap for sessile and modularlife. Grounded in the biosemiotics of Kalevi Kull and the bio-philosophy of Hans Jonas, choiceis reframed as coextensive with vegetative semiosis, where an organism resolves states ofbehavioral indeterminacy by collapsing ambiguous environmental noise into actionable somatic interpretants. Within this living sign process, valuation, attention, and decision-making form an inseparable functional continuum, wherein existential metabolic needs assign biological valence,bioelectric canalization filters salient cues from sensory noise through reciprocal feedback, andmorphogenetic growth consummates the somatic resolution of the encounter. We show that this evaluative agency is sustained by cellular cognitive biology and biological thermodynamics, wherein plants operate as autopoietic Kantian Wholes that invest metabolic work to preserve nonequilibriumorder against entropic dissipation. At the elementary level, this capacity is orchestrated by excitable plasma membranes functioning as sensory-smart borders populated by biological Maxwell's demons, which constitute the multimodal cellular senome and electrome.This framework is empirically grounded across multiple biological scales, encompassing precontact kinematic modulations and Speed-Accuracy Trade-offs in climbing tendrils, the scalar transition from polyphonic modular focus to systemic bioelectric attention and pigment reallocation during host foraging in parasitic plants, subterranean self-inhibition and territorial discrimination in foraging roots, and internal cambial vascular arbitration. Finally, by integrating Charles Sanders Peirce's typology of hypoicons, we establish that plants do not simulate choices through detached mental tokens, but materialize them directly in space. Morphogenesis constitutes living decision-making in action, demonstrating that for a vegetative organism, to grow, to attend, and to interpret the world is inherently to choose.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Basso et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: