Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background As students engage in complex engineering work for their classes, their emotional experiences have implications not only for learning but also for shaping their attitudes toward engineering and their development of engineering identity. Purpose/Hypothesis(es) This study aims (1) to understand patterns in students' emotions while engaged in complex problem‐solving and (2) to understand relationships among students' emotions during problem‐solving, engineering identity, and confidence in course‐specific learning objectives at the end of the semester. Design/Method This study examines survey data collected at the end of an engineering Statics course in which students completed an open‐ended modeling project. Quantitative analyses examine students' responses to three portions of the survey: emotions experienced throughout the project (an affective pathway), engineering identity (performance/competence, recognition, and interest), and course‐specific confidence. Through social network analysis, correlation analyses, and analysis of variance, we examine patterns in students' emotions as well as relationships between these three constructs. Results Students reported complex affective pathways, with confusion and accomplishment as central transition points. Positive mean pathway valence correlated with stronger engineering identity. Students ending the project with positively‐valenced emotions had strong course‐specific confidence, engineering interest, and performance/competence. Results also suggest course‐specific confidence is correlated with the performance/competence aspect of identity. Conclusions Affective pathways give insight into fluctuating emotional experiences that potentially shape students' engineering identity and confidence. Confusion emerged as a key emotion to help students resolve or interpret, while accomplishment stands out as an emotion to foster due to these emotions' centrality in affective pathways and ties to identity.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Treadway et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: