Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We formulate the thermodynamic core of a quaternionic crystal–glass theory. The orientational variable is an SO(3) rotor q∈SU(2), q∼−q, with coherent amplitude ρ. The rotor stiffness is retained, so disclinations enter as failures of smooth orientational continuation rather than as scalar defects inserted after the fact. A glass is not obtained by integrating out a dilute defect gas, which gives only an ordered-side fugacity correction. The glass basin is instead represented by a second field Φ, defined as the frozen part of the orientational holonomy: the disclination charge threading a loop is the conjugacy class of the loop holonomy in the binary point group H, proliferation of disclinations is the area law of the orientational Wilson loop, and Φ is the Edwards–Anderson amplitude of that holonomy, nonzero only when it is frozen. This separates the glass from a liquid, where the holonomy is equally random but not frozen, and from a defect density, which is nonzero in every phase. We construct a two-field Gibbs functional with competing crystal (ρ̸= 0,Φ = 0) and glass (ρ≃0,Φ ̸= 0) saddles. The order of the transition follows from the quartic coupling matrix: strong positive repulsion between ρand Φ gives a first-order boundary, weaker coupling permits a mixed/frustrated regime. The holonomy charge coincides with the Burgers circulation of the nonaffine displacement field in the torsion sector and differs from it in the curvature sector; in the Riemann–Cartan description of the defect density, disclinations source curvature and dislocations source torsion. The freezing of Φ follows from the rearrangement barrier σws that the functional itself defines. The theory outputs the defect correlation length, the rearrangement barrier and the bulk saddle scale required by the companion transport manuscript, without claiming that thermal conductivity follows from thermodynamics alone.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gorham et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: