Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The authors explore to what extent women charged with domestic violence–related offences, experience Domestic Violence Court programs as fulfilling their stated commitment to implement a trauma-informed and collaborative approach. The research methodology includes the facilitation of virtual two-hour focus groups and the analysis of participant-related transcripts of court appearances of fourteen women who participated in Domestic Violence Court programs in Canada. A trauma-informed framework guides the thematic analysis. The findings show that, despite a stated commitment to a trauma-informed approach, the Domestic Violence Court programs do not fulfill that commitment in practice. Further, the participants’ experiences show that many aspects of the Domestic Violence Court program are trauma-inducing. The findings support critiques of criminalisation by pointing to the need for alternative gender-responsive approaches that reduce pressure on participants to plead guilty, support their involvement in decision-making, prevent partner manipulation of court processes, and prioritise therapeutic supports. Our results highlight need to move beyond a trauma-informed approach to help situate women’s use of violence within a structural and cultural analysis. While some reform may be possible within existing systems, the author’s ultimately call for alternative, decriminalised responses that integrate trauma- and violence-informed principles.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Nancy Ross (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: