Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Around 1690, William Dunlop, Carolina colonist and Principal of the University of Glasgow, penned an outline of the advantages and disadvantages of England possessing colonies in the Americas. Among other points – relating to jurisprudence, trade, immigration, birthright citizenship, and imperial rivalries – he noted the potential for colonies breaking from England if they were subjected to laws and taxation imposed from across the Atlantic without their consent. Though he lived in an era that is considered to have had little direct parliamentary interference in colonial affairs, he envisioned future developments of centralizing imperial authority, thought the result would inspire revolution, and suggested measures to avoid that outcome. Most notably, he articulated that the colonists should have representatives in the English Parliament. An examination of Dunlop’s ideas on these matters encourages a rethinking of the chronological framework of American Revolutionary ideology as it demonstrates that the grievances and concerns of those in the eighteenth century were prefigured by those in the seventeenth. From another perspective – one that does not centre later developments – Dunlop’s analysis illuminates the viewpoint of a little known but leading thinker of his day in relation to law, liberty, and other topics as they pertained to Britain and the Americas.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Joseph Wagner (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: