Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Tokenization research in mobile and contactless payments has concentrated almost entirely on the device side of the transaction, including secure elements, biometric-gated wallets, and on-device key storage. At the same time, the network-facing infrastructure that issues, validates, and manages a token's lifecycle remains comparatively unexamined. This infrastructure spans the token service provider, token vault, issuer, and payment network, working in coordination with the acquiring switch. This article argues that token architecture decisions made across that infrastructure, not at the device or secure-element layer alone, are a binding constraint on card-present tokenization security that device-centric research tends to underweight. Drawing on documented migration from key blocks to hardware security modules and on multi-brand certification experience across four major card networks, the article develops a switch-perspective framework spanning token issuance, key management, cross-network certification validation, and authorization routing. The framework situates the acquiring switch's role, namely routing, selective data validation, and participation in cryptographic processing, within the broader infrastructure rather than treating it as the sole locus of control. The article examines how key management practices, together with certification heterogeneity across payment networks, bound the security guarantees that any device-side tokenization scheme can ultimately deliver, regardless of secure-element strength. The discussion is contextualized within the device-centric tokenization and biometric authentication literature. The contribution is a network-perspective synthesis of tokenization architecture grounded in direct certification and key-migration practice, a vantage point largely absent from device-focused mobile-wallet security research. The article concludes that network-facing key management and validation design, not endpoint hardware alone, deserves greater attention as a unit of analysis for card-present contactless transactions, and proposes key-lifecycle management practices, including rotation cadence, as an architectural security consideration alongside device-side measures
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Arun Palanisamy (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: