Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background. Earlier work reported that medical vision–language models scarcely adjust their use of diagnostic advice to its stated reliability. We tested the decision-level consequences with a separate pipeline, new patients and generated answers. Methods. A frozen local protocol, not a preregistration, specified 400 NIH ChestX-ray14 patients, balanced for effusion and selected after excluding patients with ChestX-Det thumbnail matches. MedGemma-4B and Lingshu-7B answered with no advice or either binary report from a simulated tool at 3 stated symmetric reliabilities. The primary arm disclosed the simulated error mechanism; a metadata-only arm omitted it. Primary endpoints were the change in counterfactual decision reliance, ∆R = R(0.99) − R(0.50), and the loss of balanced correct decisions with coin-flip advice, H50. We used class-stratified patient bootstrap intervals. Results. In the primary arm, coin-flip reliance was 19.8 [16.3, 23.3]% for MedGemma and 34.5 [30.8, 38.0]% for Lingshu (95% intervals). The corresponding H50 values were 6.4 [4.4, 8.4] and 10.0 [7.4, 12.6] pp. Both fell below always following a 99% tool, by 13.4 and 8.1 pp. MedGemma's ∆R was -0.3 [-1.5, 0.8] pp; Lingshu's was positive, 3.7 [2.0, 5.7] pp. Both 90% intervals lay inside the prespecified ±10 pp margin, but Lingshu's detectable response challenges blanket reliability blindness. Its positive response was supported only in the mechanism-explicit arm. Conclusion. Deference to disclosed uninformative advice and under-use of highly reliable advice replicated. Blanket blindness did not replicate for Lingshu. Generated decisions establish neither probability-level blindness nor clinical readiness; NLP-mined labels, selected normal negatives and possible training exposure limit interpretation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
S. M. Abdulla Al Mamun (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: