Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Mālik’s version of the hadith on zakat al-fitr transmitted by Nāfiʿ from Ibn ʿUmar differs from ʿUbaydillāh’s version in its inclusion of the additional phrase min al-muslimīn. This study aimed to describe variations in the wording and chains of transmission of the hadith, explain how the majority of scholars and the Hanafi school differ on the obligation to pay zakat al-fitr on behalf of enslaved non-Muslims, and analyze acceptance of the additional phrase as an application of the jamʿ method. This library-based study used a descriptive-analytical qualitative approach. Data were collected through hadith takhrīj and comparison of the wording in hadith collections, commentaries, works on Islamic jurisprudence, and literature on hadith sciences. The analysis examined the four conditions for applying jamʿ. The findings showed that both narrations are authentic and that their chains of transmission converge at Nāfiʿ and Ibn ʿUmar, with the wording differing at the level of Nāfiʿ’s students. The majority of scholars interpret the phrase min al-muslimīn as restricting the persons on whose behalf zakat al-fitr is paid, while the Hanafi school applies the restriction to those who pay it. Examination of the four conditions for jamʿ indicated that accepting the additional phrase was more consistent with the interpretation of the majority of scholars. The study shows that accepting the additional phrase can reconcile the two apparently conflicting wordings while preserving both authentic narrations.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ilham et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: