Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Integrated renewable and waste-to-energy systems couple wind, photovoltaics and storage with conversion of local biomass and organic waste by anaerobic digestion or gasification. How much of a system demonstrated on one island another community should replicate is typically decided by analogy. This paper proposes a prototype two-stage screening rule for that decision. Stage 1 computes a directional asset gap, the share of the seven component classes of a demonstrated source system that a candidate does not operate, and screens the replication scope against a threshold of 0.5: full-system replication, or replication of the coordinating energy-management layer, with a component-wise list of classes to procure or integrate. Stage 2 reports a weighted adaptation distance over the asset gap and five key-performance-indicator dimensions, with evidence coverage and per-dimension local-study flags. Applied post hoc by unblinded authors to two follower communities of one programme, the rule returned the adopted scope in both cases, with asset gaps of 1.000 and 0.286 and adaptation distances of 0.690 and 0.216 at evidence coverage of 0.75. The second selection changed only where the two missing classes weighed as much as the five operated ones (10.8% of 20,000 random weightings) or under the strictest matching rules (2 of 10 alternative vocabularies). A screening of 32 programme pairs and 15 island studies found complete pre-intervention inventories for too few cases to estimate accuracy, and with a generic source portfolio the rule missed all three management-only cases. It is a proof of concept, not a validated predictor.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Savvakis et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: