Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This article examines methodological nationalism through the case of Turkish emigration – from rural areas of Türkiye to the country’s cities and to Europe – by focusing on interpretations of the ‘factors of departure.’ Covering the period from the late 1940s to the present, the corpus comprises four sets of research: French research on Turkish immigration, Turkish research on emigration to Europe and on internal migration, and research conducted in Anatolian villages by predominantly British anthropologists. Comparing these bodies of research reveals divergences: the factors invoked in French research to explain the arrival of Turkish populations in France differ from those to which Turkish research attributes their departure from Türkiye. It also reveals unexpected convergences: the same factors explain, in French research, the arrival of Turks in France and, in Turkish research, the arrival of rural populations in the country’s cities twenty years earlier. Anthropological research, for its part, challenges the explanations advanced in the other three sets. These divergences and convergences reveal a transversal dimension insufficiently captured by existing typologies: the national perspective from which research questions are formulated and explanations are constructed. Building on Abdelmalek Sayad’s analyses, the article presents this perspective as the product of a double dependence on state categories and the collective elaborations specific to each society. It proposes the notion of ‘methodological mono-nationalism’, which refers to the tendency to apprehend migration from the perspective of a single national society. Two configurations – binational and plurinational – are distinguished according to the scope of the fieldwork, along with two modes – individualistic and holistic – according to the explanatory registers applied to departures. Overcoming this bias requires confronting research structured by the respective perspectives of societies of arrival and departure.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Elif Aksaz (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: