Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background and purpose: Pedagogical and Curriculum Models (PMs) have become increasingly prominent in Physical Education (PE), with research often emphasizing their benefits for student learning. However, less attention has been paid to the difficulties teachers encounter when enacting PMs in everyday practice. The aim of this study was to explore PE teachers’ lived experiences of enacting established PMs, focusing on the difficulties and insecurities they experience and the contextual factors shaping their enactment.Methods: A qualitative study with a phenomenological–hermeneutic orientation was conducted to examine teachers’ lived experiences and interpretations of PM enactment. Twelve PE teachers (seven women and five men) with more than ten years of experience in public primary and secondary schools in Spain participated. All had received formal and/or informal training in established pedagogical and curriculum PMs, including Cooperative Learning, Teaching Games for Understanding, Teaching Personal and Social Responsibility, and Sport Education. Data were generated through weekly reflective teaching diaries completed over a 12-week period and individual semi-structured interviews. Data were analysed thematically using a deductive approach informed by the study’s theoretical framework, with triangulation of data sources used to enhance trustworthiness. Results: Three interconnected themes were identified. First, teachers described their training in PMs as limited and decontextualized, generating difficulties when translating theoretical principles into classroom practice and often leading to frustration, self-doubt, and feelings of incompetence. Second, participants reported experiencing implicit pressures to adopt PMs through curricular expectations, professional development activities, academic discourse, and comparisons with colleagues. Although no formal obligation existed, many felt compelled to demonstrate alignment with dominant pedagogical trends. Third, teachers highlighted tensions between PMs and their professional identities. Rather than replacing existing practices, they tended to selectively adapt and integrate elements of PMs within their established pedagogical approaches.Conclusion: The enactment of PMs is shaped not only by teachers’ pedagogical knowledge but also by broader social, symbolic, and curricular influences that affect professional identity and decision-making. These findings highlight the importance of supporting teachers through sustained, contextualized, and practice-oriented professional learning processes.IMPACT STATEMENTThis study contributes a critical and context-sensitive perspective on PM enactment by foregrounding PE teachers’ lived experiences. The findings challenge idealized representations of PMs and highlight the need for teacher education and professional development initiatives that better address the complexities of classroom practice, thereby supporting more realistic and sustainable pedagogical innovation in PE.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Alcalá et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: