Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Droplet size distribution governs the stability and sensory properties of cosmetic emulsions. Many cosmetic emulsions are lamellar. Each droplet carries a birefringent shell and is a core-shell object. Laser diffraction is the usual sizing technique. Its Mie inversion requires a single refractive index. This index is poorly defined for a droplet with a lamellar shell. Optical microscopy avoids this assumption. It measures each droplet directly on the image, whatever its refractive index. Combined with image segmentation, it offers an independent sizing route. We compared laser diffraction with a classical watershed and a deep-learning model (Cellpose) on 13 lamellar emulsions imaged at ×10, ×20, and ×40. Diameters were calibrated from the instrument metadata and reweighted to volume. Cellpose and laser diffraction give the same central size. Their dv50 differ by less than 1.5 µm on all 13 emulsions at ×10. Paired tests show no significant dv50 difference at ×10 and ×40 (adjusted p ≥ 0.13). The watershed reaches this agreement only on the coarsest emulsions. It overestimates the dv50 of the finer ones by 15 to 35% and fails at ×40. The two techniques differ only at the ends of the distribution. At the upper end, laser diffraction gives a higher dv90 than microscopy. A non-spherical laser model does not remove this gap. Possible causes are the smoothing of the laser inversion and the evolution of the sample under dilution. At the lower end, microscopy gives a higher dv10 because it does not detect droplets below its optical resolution. The same slides also reveal the lamellar shell under crossed polarizers. Deep-learning microscopy is thus a quantitative sizing method for the central size of lamellar emulsions. The two techniques are complementary for the characterization of lamellar emulsions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Viton et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: