Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
INTRODUCTION: Changes to the Ionising Radiation (Medical Exposure) Regulations and a recommendation from the Care Quality Commission (CQC) encouraged modification of pregnancy enquiry procedures to account for transgender patients. The CQC's explicit concern was addressing risk of missed pregnancy in female patients whose sex was replaced with a gender identity in health records or who had a masculinised appearance. METHODS: Freedom of Information requests were sent to UK National Health Services asking for standard operating procedures (SOPs) for pregnancy and breastfeeding enquiries before ionising radiation exposure. RESULTS: 162 health services provided SOPs directing operators to one of four strategies: 1) individually judge patient sex to decide whom to target for pregnancy enquiries (55%, 89/162); 2) ask patients their sex and make enquiry of females (31%, 50/162); 3) ask patients if they could be pregnant, irrespective of appearance or whether their health record says male or female (14%, 22/162); 4) ask patients first about gender identity discordance, then if present about sex, and then pregnancy if female or "identifying as female" (1%, 1/162). Sex was considered, presented and enquired of variably. The nature of pregnancy as an exclusively female state was sometimes misrepresented. Desexed alternatives partly or fully replaced "female," "women," "girls" or "mothers" in 91% (147/162) of SOPs. "Chestfeeding" was used in 16% (21/135) of breastfeeding SOPs. Most SOPs (75%, 122/162) lacked information to assist operators ascertain or care for transgender-identifying female patients. The majority (57%, 93/162) directed information collection beyond recommendations. CONCLUSION: Changes made to include transgender patients were variable, inconsistent and purely linguistic or included males. This presents risks, ranging from fetal harm to reputational damage. IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: Sex should be accurately recorded in health records and sex-specific language used when sex is relevant. Changes to health care procedures or language should be tested and only recommended with evidence of benefit.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Roberts et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: