Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Research on employee vigour has largely relied on the assumption that more vigour is always better. However, maintaining extremely high vigour may become depleting rather than beneficial because it impairs self-regulatory capacity and limits recovery, particularly in resource-limiting leadership contexts. Integrating insights from self-regulation and effort-recovery perspectives with conservation of resources theory, we investigated whether employee vigour exhibits diminishing returns for affective organisational commitment through emotional exhaustion, and whether leader vigour shapes these effects. We tested this assumption with a curvilinear moderated mediation model using a three-wave, cross-level survey design with 752 human services employees nested within 117 leaders. Results showed that when employee vigour gets very high, its benefits level off; it no longer reduces emotional exhaustion or boosts affective commitment meaningfully. In addition, when leader vigour is low, employees with very high vigour actually feel more exhausted, which reduces their affective organisational commitment. By unpacking why, how, and when extremely high vigour may become detrimental for employee functioning, we advance a more nuanced understanding of the costs and benefits of employees’ energetic resource investment, and highlight the importance of managing vigour sustainably. Overall, our findings suggest that, although vigour is generally beneficial, extremely high levels may become depleting.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
SHEE et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: