Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This article challenges Fernando Vidal’s (1994) thesis that Jean Piaget’s early writings document a passage from transcendence to immanence between La Mission de l'idée (1915) and Les mystères de la douleur divine (1916). It argues that Piaget was never fully situated within the paradigm of classical transcendence. Already in 1915, the operative structure of his thought—the Idea defined as a living organism, the explicit denial of divine omnipotence , the immanent explanation of evil, and the coconstitutive eschatology in which God recovers his power through human labor —systematically contradicts the religious vocabulary inherited from the Swiss Reformed tradition . The difference between the two texts is not structural but lexical: What Vidal reads as a rupture is, in fact, a radicalization of tendencies already present, reorganized by reflexive abstraction . The article combines close textual exegesis with intellectual historical contextualization (Sabatier and Bergson), distinguishing lexical surface from deep structure . It hypothesizes that the coconstitutive matrix of 1915–1916 is not lost in the mature work but transliterated as operative structure, whose coconstitution with the subject's activity is the core of genetic epistemology . The roots of Piagetian constructivism are thus deeper and more continuous than the canonical narrative suggests.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Anselmo de Lima Chaves (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: