Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Introduction: Research suggests broad categories of risk and risk stratification tools do not accurately predict risk of self-ham and suicide. Clinical guidelines and suicide prevention strategies in several countries confirm that they should not be used. However, it is unclear how services should move from suicide risk stratification and tools toward a more personalized assessment approach in practice. In this paper, we describe how three mental health organizations in England made this change. Aims: For each organization, we describe the rationale for change, how the change was implemented, preliminary outcomes and impacts of the new risk assessment approach. We also outline barriers to change and how these were overcome. Impact: In these three organizations with a combined catchment population of over 4 million people, services were able to move away from traditional approaches to risk assessment. There were reported improvements in assessment completion, documentation, recorded patient and carer involvement, and staff satisfaction after implementing new approaches to risk. Limitations: Outcome data were limited to audit information and feedback from clinicians and patients. Conclusions: A move away from practice based on categories of suicide risk is possible and personalized approaches to risk show promise for greater collaboration between staff, patients, and carers. Meaningful lived experience and clinical involvement throughout the process is crucial. This was not a formal research study or service evaluation. Further rigorous evaluation of clinical outcomes is needed to ensure that new approaches lead to safer, more therapeutic assessments.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rivart et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: