Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This study examined the stability of adoption and special guardianship (SG) orders in England by analysing administrative data for 70,170 adoptions (2004–2023) and 48,020 SG orders (2006–2023) on children who had been in care. The disruption rates were low. After eight years, disruption rates were significantly lower for adoptions (2%) than for SG orders (10%). The strongest predictor of disruption was the child’s older age at the time of the order, particularly for children adopted at age 5–10. Longer time in care increased the risk of disruption for adopted children, whereas for SG children, leaving care within a year heightened the risk. Multiple foster placements before the order raised disruption risk, especially for adopted children. For SG children, absent parenting as the initial reason for care, being a Black child, and orders made to kinship carers were associated with higher hazards. After disruption, adopted children experienced multiple placements more often than SG children, including in residential settings and more often remained in care. The findings highlight the importance of timely decision-making, minimising placement moves, and targeted support for older children and SG arrangements. Adoption remains more stable than SG, but both require robust post-order support to prevent breakdowns.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Selwyn et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: