Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The Charpy impact energy of ferritic steels varies sigmoidally with temperature, and the resulting ductile-to-brittle transition (DBT) curve is commonly described by a hyperbolic-tangent (tanh) equation. This study compares the following two ways of learning this curve from heterogeneous literature data: direct regression of the impact energy, and an equation-constrained approach in which the learner predicts the four tanh parameters and is trained end-to-end through the equation. A database of 604 Charpy V-notch measurements from 40 publications (58 steels) was compiled and supplemented with physics-derived descriptors, and six tree and neural-network models were tuned under the same protocol. Under random cross-validation the five models that use all measurements reach R2 = 0.71–0.89, but when whole steels are held out, R2 falls to 0.12–0.32. The equation-constrained models return smooth sigmoids with interpretable parameters at a similar accuracy under the grouped schemes, but the transition temperatures predicted for unseen steels remain uncertain (mean absolute errors of 35–41 °C). On four in-house quenched-and-tempered cast steels tested between −40 and 25 °C, the equation-constrained network had the lowest mean absolute error (28 J; other models 44–55 J), a ranking that depends on network settings and on the values assumed for unanalysed elements. Adaptation with three cast steels reduced the error on the fourth to 21–29 J for all models, no lower than a curve fitted to the cast data alone. SHAP attributed the transition temperature and the upper-shelf energy mainly to carbon and tempering.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Seo et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: