Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Urban landscapes are increasingly exposed to the impacts of climate change, soil depletion, and aesthetic–functional degradation. In this context, nature-based solutions (NbS) offer an integrated approach to restoring ecosystem services by merging agronomic expertise with careful landscape design. However, the pressing urgency to ‘green’ cities has fostered the proliferation of false nature-based solutions (FNbS), defined here as interventions whose claimed environmental benefits are unsupported or contradicted by evidence. This study critically analyzes the dichotomy between authentic NbS and FNbS in urban and peri-urban landscape restoration, distinguishing FNbS from underperforming and maladaptive interventions. Through a structured narrative review and critical synthesis of the literature, this paper proposes a provisional assessment framework that shifts the focus toward long-term agronomic performance and landscape coherence. The model organizes the assessment based on parameters such as the conservation and enhancement of soil fertility, site-specific species selection, the physiological resilience of species, and harmonious integration into the pre-existing connective tissue, along five axes—soil, vegetation, water, heritage, and social equity and health—each with data requirements, indicators, warning signs, and decision rules for mixed or incomplete evidence. The framework is mapped onto the IUCN Global Standard and requires empirical validation. The objective is to provide transparent guidelines for designers and policymakers, ensuring that new urban green systems are not merely temporary scenography, but truly resilient ecosystems rooted in the agronomic and identity dynamics of the territory.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Marabini et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: