Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Incremental deployment of hollow-core fiber (HCF) in single-mode-fiber (SMF) networks introduces a routing trade-off: reducing HCF–SMF transitions can improve physical-layer feasibility, but overly transition-averse routing incurs harmful path detours. We study it with a common event-driven simulator comparing six protected routing schemes—fiber-blind, generalized signal-to-noise ratio (GSNR)-aware, and explicitly transition-aware—on hybrid HCF/SMF topologies, using a per-transition GSNR penalty and an exploratory splice-failure availability term. Across six reference topologies, five HCF deployment fractions, and dynamic loads, the strongest minimizers—transition-penalty-aware routing (TPAR) and the GSNR/fiber-transition joint scheme (GFJ)—halve the mean transition count at a 20%–25% carried-traffic penalty. Among the intermediate designs, GSNR-maximal routing with transition-aware reranking (GMR-T) cuts transitions by ∼21% versus distance-adaptive routing and spectrum assignment (DA-RSA) at a 6% throughput cost under heavy load, while below the blocking knee bounded-detour TPAR (BD-TPAR) removes ∼12% of them at no measurable throughput cost. Contiguous HCF rollout lowers transitions by ∼42% on average while improving carried traffic, reducing the benefit of aggressive transition-aware routing, and the ranking survives sweeps of the per-transition penalty, of the differential-delay allowance, and of the node-level HCF–SMF interface loss every HCF span carries. These results support GMR-T as the practical default at heavy load, BD-TPAR at moderate load, and TPAR/GFJ only where external transition cost is high.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Saber et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: