Key result
Myocardial-work indices had minimal incremental influence on cardiac profile allocation beyond standard measures and GLS, with 95/97 participants retaining cluster membership when excluded.
Why the study?
Does integrated myocardial work phenotyping provide incremental value beyond standard echocardiographic measures and global longitudinal strain in differentiating cardiac profiles between professional football players and non-professional comparators?
Cross-Sectional (n=97)
Does integrated myocardial work phenotyping provide incremental value beyond standard echocardiographic measures and global longitudinal strain in differentiating cardiac profiles between professional football players and non-professional comparators?
Myocardial-work indices describe pressure-strain and efficiency patterns in athletes vs non-athletes but offer minimal incremental value over standard echocardiographic chamber size, hemodynamic, and GLS measures for phenotyping.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Myocardial-work indices should not yet guide athlete cardiac profiling; leaves open incremental value in other populations or for outcomes.
To explore integrated cardiac profiles in professional football players and non-professional comparators and assess their sensitivity to demographic, body-size and haemodynamic differences. This cross-sectional analysis included 49 professional players (39 men, 10 women) and 48 hospital-staff comparators recruited as healthy volunteers (31 men, 17 women). Principal component analysis (PCA) of 28 standardised clinical, echocardiographic, deformation and myocardial-work measures preceded k-means clustering without study-group labels. Sensitivity analyses addressed age, sex, blood pressure, body-size indexing and exclusion of myocardial work while retaining global longitudinal strain (GLS). Five components explained 62.2% of variance. The three-profile solution had a silhouette coefficient of 0.252 and mean resampling adjusted Rand index (ARI) of 0.820. Profile A contained 55 participants, including 41 players (74.5%); profiles B and C contained 4/17 and 4/25 players. Profile A combined larger chambers with preserved global work efficiency; profile B had higher systolic and diastolic blood pressure, greater wasted work and lower efficiency. Age-adjusted and jointly age-, sex- and blood-pressure-adjusted analyses yielded agreement ARIs of 0.448 and 0.097. Without myocardial work, 95/97 participants and all 49 players retained profile membership (ARI 0.950). Integrated phenotyping identified overlapping cardiac profiles associated with professional football, principally reflecting chamber size, demographics and loading conditions. Myocardial-work indices described pressure-strain and efficiency patterns but had little additional influence on profile allocation beyond the remaining measures, including GLS. Their incremental clinical utility requires external validation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Salicio et al. (2026) conducted a cross-sectional in Cardiac adaptation in professional football players versus healthy non-professional comparators (n=97). Integrated myocardial work phenotyping (PCA and k-means clustering of 28 clinical, echocardiographic, deformation, and myocardial-work measures) vs. Non-professional hospital-staff healthy volunteers (and clustering without myocardial work measures) was evaluated on Cardiac profile allocation and cluster membership retention (Profile A membership and agreement by adjusted Rand index). Myocardial-work indices had minimal incremental influence on cardiac profile allocation beyond standard measures and GLS, with 95/97 participants retaining cluster membership when excluded.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: