Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Over the past decade, reionization studies have yielded persistent factor-of-2-to-5 disagreements in the inferred ionizing escape fraction f esc and peak star formation efficiency f *,0 , compounded by JWST’s discovery of unexpectedly bright z > 10 galaxies. We show that this discrepancy arises from a structural degeneracy that is exact at fixed dark matter parameters: the ionizing photon rate n ̇ ion ∝ f esc × f * , 0 renders the emissivity-based probes including Thomson optical depth, the neutral hydrogen fraction from quasar and galaxy damping wings, and the Ly α luminosity function. are sensitive only to the product f esc × f *,0 , while the UV luminosity function fixes f *,0 alone; once the dark matter parameters are allowed to vary, rematching the UVLF also nearly restores the ionizing emissivity, producing a joint dark matter– f *,0 – f esc degeneracy that renders the mapping effectively nonidentifiable at current observational precision. We demonstrate the robustness of this degeneracy using a large suite of N -body simulations of self-interacting dark matter halos spanning 10 9 –10 11 M ⊙ . Despite substantial changes to galaxy-scale structure, observables remain indistinguishable once the effective ionizing emissivity is matched, severely limiting reionization-based dark matter probes. Among the reionization-history probes, only observables sensitive to the spatial morphology of ionized regions are structurally orthogonal to the global emissivity normalisation; sufficiently precise independent measurements of the underlying galaxy parameters could also break the degeneracy. Our results provide a unified explanation for the scatter among published constraints and establish a framework for interpreting reionization observations and their implications for early galaxy formation and dark matter.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Wang et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: