Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Tipping transitions are abrupt reorganisations in which a system leaves one statistical regime for another. Their anticipation is usually framed through critical slowing down: recovery becomes slower, autocorrelation rises, variance may increase and spectral power shifts towards low frequencies. For noisy, spatially extended systems, however, these scalar signatures do not by themselves reveal which part of the dynamics is losing resilience, whether rare excursions towards a competing state are becoming more likely, or whether the spatial field is reorganising before the transition. We examine these complementary questions in the stochastic Ghil–Sellers energy balance model, a latitudinally resolved climate model whose ice–albedo feedback supports warm and snowball metastable regimes. We follow three complementary viewpoints rather than aiming at a single universal indicator. Reduced Ruelle–Pollicott resonances and Kolmogorov modes diagnose relaxation and response in physically interpretable observables; extreme-value theory probes the accessibility and persistence of excursions into the tails; and data-adaptive harmonic modes (DAHMs) diagnose the frequency-resolved organisation of the full temperature field. Near tipping, several reduced decay rates slow together and their modes become geometrically harmonised along a common transition direction. The associated Green functions develop delayed-recovery tails and enhanced low-frequency susceptibility only when the relevant response residues are non-zero. When approaching the warm-to-snowball bifurcation, the cold extremes of the Ghil–Sellers model become less sharply bounded and more clustered, while the full field becomes less compressible at fixed DAHM rank and its phase distribution broadens, even as a dominant low-frequency transition component emerges. The resulting picture goes beyond critical slowing down. Early warning is more comprehensively viewed as a question of which component of the dynamics is reorganising, through which observable, towards which transition channel and at which level of spatial description. Slow relaxation, directional tail excursions and loss of full-field phase coherence are distinct physical manifestations of the approach to a critical transition, and their joint interpretation provides a more informative basis for early-warning analysis in high-dimensional stochastic systems. We further show that a small localised change in the albedo parametrisation can create an additional pair of folds, illustrating that a distance to tipping may carry structural model uncertainty in addition to statistical uncertainty.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Chekroun et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: