Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In punching a boxing bag, a salient source of information for the movement effect is the felt impact. Using virtual reality (VR), we manipulated the haptic information specifying the impact, to test if indeed the advantage of external focus relates to attention toward the movement effect. Twenty-four participants (18 males, 6 females) performed a punching task under both internal and external focus of attention instructions across two separate sessions. Participants wore a VR headset and punched a bag in two conditions: a virtual bag (without haptic information on the movement effect) and physical bag (with haptic information). Hand velocity at impact functioned as the performance measure. Linear mixed-effects model analysis revealed a significant main effect of attentional focus, with higher punching velocity under external compared to internal focus of attention. A significant main effect of bag was also observed, with higher velocity when striking the physical bag compared to the virtual bag. Critically, the interaction of attentional focus and bag condition was not significant, indicating that the advantage of external focus of attention was preserved regardless of the availability of haptic information related to movement effects. This finding challenges the explanation from common coding theory that the advantage of an external focus is due to its attention for movement effect. Rather, it is consistent with an ecological perspective that external focus is superior because it fosters attunement to task relevant information specifying the dynamic relation between the fist and the target.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sanjani et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: