Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This study develops an operational regime-comparison framework for examining centralized and decentralized decision-making for the same cargo owners in a common port logistics system. The framework integrates cargo-owner-specific flow dynamics, multimodal inland evacuation, stochastic and load-dependent service, appointment allocation and payment, and voluntary participation under explicit compensation funding. Centralized and decentralized regimes differ in decision authority, information, objectives, and access rules while sharing the same physical environment and system-cost accounting. PPO and IPPO are used to obtain approximate feedback policies for the two regimes, with matched simulation experiments, nonlearning benchmarks, sensitivity analyses, extended training, and fixed-policy out-of-sample tests used to examine the resulting comparisons. The results reveal distinct advantages rather than uniform dominance across all performance dimensions. The centralized regime generally achieves lower system operating costs, reduces downstream accumulation after admission, and aligns endogenous release requests more closely with available appointment capacity. Its relative cost advantage becomes more pronounced when appointment capacity is scarce and when greater inland capacity provides more discretion over release timing and mode allocation. The decentralized regime, however, can evacuate more cargo within the finite operating horizon while preserving cargo-owner autonomy. Routine service uncertainty produces little change in the relative cost gap.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Dou et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: