Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Underground hydrogen storage (UHS) in porous formations is critical for renewable energy balancing, yet hydrogen losses due to relative permeability hysteresis during cyclic injection-withdrawal operations remain uncertain because current simulations rely on conventional hysteresis models assuming strongly water-wet conditions and monotonic trapping curves—assumptions that may not hold where wettability departs from strongly water-wet conditions. The Spiteri wettability-dependent relative permeability hysteresis model was implemented in an open-source reservoir simulator, Open Porous Media (OPM) Flow, with numerically stable formulations. Model parameters (α, β, γ) were calibrated using pore-network simulations on Berea sandstone micro-CT images under water-wet and mixed-wet conditions (average contact angles θ of 20° and 100° respectively), capturing a non-monotonic relation between trapped and initial gas saturation absent in the traditional Land model. Field-scale simulations were performed on a heterogeneous aquifer model at 840 m depth, 9 MPa initial pressure, and 40 °C, with an average horizontal permeability of 269 mD, porosity of 0.20, and a cycling rate of 200,000 sm 3 /day over five annual injection-withdrawal cycles, comparing four scenarios: no hysteresis, and cases using the Killough, Carlson, and Spiteri hysteresis functions. The results show that wettability strongly influences recovery for the bounding cases considered. Under water-wet conditions, the models provide similar estimates of cyclic recovery (79.8–81.1%). Under mixed-wet conditions, the predictions of the models differ significantly: first-cycle recoveries span 21.7 percentage points (Carlson: 84.6%, Killough: 70.4%, Spiteri: 62.9%), narrowing to 7.1 points by cycle five (95.7%, 91.5%, 88.6%). Carlson's optimistic predictions contradict pore-network evidence, while the Spiteri model reproduces validated non-monotonic trends. Grid-scale analysis reveals that the Carlson model predicts minimal hysteresis for the mixed-wet case, while the Killough model results in intermediate behaviour, and the Spiteri formulation predicts complex spatially-variable non-monotonic trapping and flow characteristics. For five years of cyclic operation, the difference between the Carlson and Spiteri models represents approximately 7% unrecoverable hydrogen. This work bridges pore-scale physics and field performance, demonstrating that physically grounded wettability-dependent models are essential for UHS assessment with the provision of open-source tools for reliable hydrogen storage design.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Alobaidan et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: