Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Return of personal chemical exposure results to participants has become increasingly common in the fields of environmental health and epidemiology. Report-back can build trust, stimulate learning, and encourage exposure reduction behaviors. Participants often receive and navigate results reports independently, but facilitated report-back may offer additional benefits. Though many environmental biomonitoring studies include clinical staff in their research teams, the potential for clinicians to facilitate report-back remains largely unexplored. We partnered with two clinic-based studies, Puerto Rico Testsite for Exploring Contamination Threats (PROTECT) and Environmental Reproductive and Glucose Outcomes (ERGO), to return urinary measurements of phthalates and phenols. Participants were randomly assigned to receive results either during a meeting with a clinician or independently online. Pre- and post-surveys assessed emotional response, satisfaction, knowledge, perceived self-efficacy, behavior, attitudes towards the study, and perceptions of clinician report-back. In total, 163 participants received report-back and completed both surveys. Semi-structured interviews with a subset of participants in the clinician-guided group ( n = 32) further explored this group’s experiences. Clinician-guided and self-guided groups were similar across most outcomes. Both experienced strong positive emotions (e.g. feeling respected, empowered), reported high satisfaction, and engaged in behaviors to reduce exposures. More than half of participants reported changes to everyday habits to reduce exposures following report-back, but participants reported less confidence about collective actions. In PROTECT, where participating nurses were members of the research team, clinician-guided participants reported increased confidence about understanding the study’s purposes and improved accuracy in two conceptual questions about endocrine disruption. Interviewees appreciated clinicians’ support with interpreting results and opportunities to discuss personal exposure sources and reduction. Some highlighted the structure of a scheduled appointment, which created dedicated time for reviewing results, as a benefit. Clinician-guided report-back was most effective when clinicians were already embedded in research teams. Support was valued by participants and may boost study understanding and engagement. Future work could explore whether benefits extend to report-back facilitated by researchers or other study staff. Given similarities in outcomes between both groups, self-guided report-back also remains an effective way to share results. ClinicalTrials.gov NCT06074159. Registered 9/14/2023.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Franz et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: