Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Unfounded beliefs, including conspiracy theories, misinformation, and science denial, persist despite increasing access to education and accurate information. Epistemic-Social Motivated Reasoning (ESMR) has been proposed as a dispositional susceptibility to such beliefs, reflecting reasoning directed toward psychologically comfortable, self-protective conclusions rather than toward accuracy. In a cross-sectional sample of 751 Australian adults, a bifactor model was used to test whether theoretically linked traits, including dichotomous thinking, narcissism, psychological reactance, epistemic rigidity, need for uniqueness, and social cynicism, form a coherent general factor. A multidimensional general ESMR factor emerged and was associated with belief in conspiracy theories, negative vaccine attitudes, and rejection of climate science. These associations held after accounting for established demographic, cognitive and ideological correlates, including education, social dominance orientation, intellectual humility, intuitive thinking, and political identity, and tended to be stronger among the more educated. In a latent structural equation model, ESMR was associated with these beliefs over and above conspiracy mentality, one of the strongest known dispositional correlates of these outcomes, supporting ESMR as a disposition related to unfounded belief across domains. If supported in future studies, this holds potential to inform interventions in harmful beliefs to complement existing approaches.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tylor J. Cosgrove (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: