Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Human rights are being regarded as a trump card for every social issue. Student Human Rights Ordinances, promulgated by six local governments of the Republic of Korea, are traces of such inclination. They were enacted to protect students’ rights, especially by prohibiting corporal punishment. However, a recent case of a schoolteacher’s suicide compels a reconsideration of the ordinances from a different perspective. Jeremy Bentham’s theory provides a useful insight. According to his theory, the natural rights theory fails to specify rights in relation to duties, allowing unreasonable claims to be considered as ‘human rights’. Moreover, since it does not deliberate on duties sufficiently, it cannot distribute duties justly, imposing excessive duties upon certain individuals. Situations at schools after the introduction of the ordinances are a typical example of the reverse effects of it. The duty-based approach, which can be derived from Bentham, adopts duties as the starting point and defines rights accordingly. It takes note of duties that do not correlate with rights, which are neglected in the natural rights theory and seeks to distribute different duties to diverse agents. Such an approach to addressing students’ hardships can tackle the underlying structural issues of society and establish attainable rights.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Youngsun et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: