Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Cooperative ownership is often assumed to align the interests of members with those of the organization they collectively own. This article examines whether that assumption holds for Lazan'i Betsileo (LB), a farmer-owned wine company in Madagascar's Haute Matsiatra region, by analysing farmers simultaneously as producers, shareholders, suppliers, and principals overseeing a managerial agent. The study is a qualitative single case based exclusively on secondary company documents; no primary data were collected. Five theoretical perspectives (new institutional economics, principal-agent theory, collective action, exit-voice, and member heterogeneity) serve as complementary lenses, not as hypotheses to be tested. Three patterns emerge. First, LB's formal governance structure (a general assembly, a twelve-member board, and 625 farmers who became shareholders at the 1992 conversion into a société anonyme – a public limited company) is documented alongside a period, from 1985 to a recovery that the records date to 2007, that company records describe as one of weak management oversight attributed to limited shareholder financial and commercial literacy. Second, the company reports about 1,500 affiliated growers, so ownership and supply appear organizationally distinct; the two figures, however, refer to different dates and are not disaggregated by shareholder status, so differences in prices, payments, or participation cannot be assessed. Third, company records link recurring payment delays since 1998 to reduced deliveries and withdrawal, which is consistent with exit rather than voice but cannot be attributed to a single cause. The article offers an exploratory, context-bound account of how formal ownership and effective control can diverge and proposes an agenda for comparing shareholder-members and non-shareholding suppliers.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ousman Razafimamonjy Andrianimbahoaka (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: