Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
People impacted by cancer often encounter large volumes of misleading or conflicting information. Supporting people to critically appraise such information is a key challenge. Narrative scenarios offer an engaging way to present real-world examples of health claims, encouraging reflection and critical thinking. This paper describes the co-design of a scenario-based learning resource and explore performance differences between scenario-based and knowledge-check items among people impacted by cancer. Mixed-methods formative evaluation. Multi-stage co-design integrated real-world social media examples and fictional case stories, with iterative testing and input from oncology clinicians and people impacted by cancer. Development was guided by narrative, situated, adult and social learning theories, and critical thinking theories principles. Forty-two participants enrolled; 33 completed the evaluation; item-type analyses used the 19 participants who completed all nine units. Significant differences in performance were observed between knowledge-based and narrative scenario-based items in four of nine learning resource units. Across all units, participants scored higher on narrative scenario-based questions than on knowledge-based questions, with a mean difference of 0.064 (95% CI [0.019, 0.109]; p = 0.008). Qualitative findings showed that narrative scenarios helped contextualize abstract critical thinking principles into relatable stories that reflected participants’ lived experiences and supported critical appraisal. Narrative scenarios appear feasible and acceptable as a method to support knowledge and critical thinking in people seeking cancer-related information. This study offers a practical, theory-informed model for co-designing educational tools in cancer and other health contexts.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Li et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: