Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Agonistic peace, which centres on encouraging contestation and multiplicity rather than enforcing consensus, has been identified as a potential alternative to the liberal model of peacebuilding. The contestation-centred model, proponents argue, allows for the potential transformation of underlying conflict dynamics without requiring that individuals and groups give up their identities. Recent studies on agonistic peace have shown that agonism is capable of overcoming its supposed ‘institutional deficit’, but these studies do not address how it is possible for these agonistic institutions (or agonistic elements within institutions) to develop in the first place. This study aims to answer these questions by analysing the emergence of agonism in an institution already noted for its embrace of agonistic principles: the Colombian Truth Commission. The paper adopts an interpretive approach to process tracing to offer an account of the actors, beliefs, and institutions involved in developing the Truth Commission’s agonistic methodology and operations. Using original interviews and discourse analysis of documents from both the Truth Commission and earlier truth-seeking and memorialisation initiatives in Colombia, we trace the role of discourses of resistance, including Indigenous and Afro-Colombian practices of resistance, and feminist anti-militarist mobilisation, throughout key moments in Colombia’s history of violence and attempts to build peace. We then show how these discourses and actors circulated ideas to foster the development of a truth commission rooted in principles of multiplicity, contestation, and intersectionality. These insights offer critical lessons for creating new pathways for innovative institutional design that might strengthen democratic practices in a new political turn in the country.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Murphy et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: