Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Critical organizations, whose missions involve producing social critique, such as academic, journalistic, and activist organizations, face what we term a dilemma of “critical positionality,” meaning that they must respond to contradictory demands for critical proximity and distance. This dilemma arises because legitimate critique must remain “close to the ground” to access “lived experiences” yet also adopt sufficient distance from practice to allow for problematization. Critical positionality is an organizational challenge that is exacerbated during moments of digital transitions, when proximity and distance are reconfigured through transmediality—that is, movement of content across media types—which can disrupt organizational practices oriented toward critical positionality. To understand how organizations navigate digital transmediality to maintain their critical positions, we studied a Brazilian progressive news outlet during a digital transition. Organizational attempts to build proximity to users were followed by a reactive attempt at repositioning, which cascaded into further efforts to stabilize a position consistent with the organization’s critical mission. By analyzing approximation and distancing dynamics, we contribute to understanding critical positionality in practice, discussing how critique is shaped by evolving requirements of digital transmediality, and illustrating organizational tensions developed in this process in a critical news outlet.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Islam et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: