Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Low-carbon binders from urban concrete are proposed for geothermal, carbon dioxide (CO2) and hydrogen storage wells. However, evidence supporting this comes from ambient-temperature tests conducted on elements that can be inspected and repaired. This critical review asks which of it remains valid underground. Evidence was graded by test conditions, and a design procedure was applied to three UK wells at 12, 73 and 180 °C. Binder chemistry and carbon accounting methods were identified as mechanisms of transfer, while quantitative values did not transfer due to variations in temperature, placement and boundary conditions. A four-question transfer test developed in this study demonstrated that three out of fifteen surface results could be transferred as design values. At 180 °C, a stoichiometric balance indicated an upper bound of 47.6% silica by weight of cement, compared with 35 to 50% in common practice. At 73 °C, under the stated design basis, the pressure window limited clinker replacement to 24%, or 8% for calcined clay, which was significantly lower than the 50% replacement rate observed in surface practice. Furthermore, no retained record reported well-cementing emission factors for slag or calcined clay or a functional unit. Satellite radar (InSAR) can detect ground deformation, but it cannot verify the integrity of the sheath. The modelled uplift from a source at 1800 m fell below the radar’s detection range. Future research should define a functional unit per sealed metre and conduct tests at different temperatures to ensure the accuracy of the transfer of binder chemistry and carbon accounting methods.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rahmani et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: