Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The Edirne Bimarhane was one of the long-standing healthcare institutions of the Ottoman Empire. Its establishment as a sultanic foundation and its construction in a former capital enabled the institution to maintain its function for centuries and survive to the present day. Rendered inactive after the Turco–Russian War of 1877–1878, the Bimarhane was reopened in 1895 and designated for the treatment of patients with mental illnesses. Owing to its structure and mode of operation, the institution attracted the attention of both local and foreign scholars. Two issues, in particular, have come to dominate discussions of the Bimarhane: treatment with music ( musicothérapie ) and the chaining of patients. These two sensational themes have occupied a prominent place in studies on the institution. This article examines a newspaper report dated 1908 that claimed patients at the Edirne Bimarhane were treated by being chained, together with a report prepared in response to that claim. Drawing on this report – which provides detailed information on the institution’s working mechanism, the treatment methods applied to patients, and the identities of its staff – the article reconstructs the condition of the Edirne Bimarhane in the early 20th century and clarifies the issue of chaining patients. In addition, it analyses the place of the allegation that patients were chained – an accusation regarded as an image problem because it was seen to damage the prestige of the state during the reign of Abdulhamid II – within the contemporary foreign press regime. The sources of the study consist primarily of Ottoman archival documents, as well as reports published in the domestic and foreign press and authored scholarly works.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hızlı et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: