Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Large ungulate populations often occur at overabundant densities, threatening biodiversity and ecosystem functioning. However, management strategies still lack operational and reliable indicators to define sustainable population levels that safeguard vegetation and ecosystem integrity. Here, we first evaluate which herbivore-induced damage to woody plants (browsing, rubbing, trampling, or stem-breaking) best reflects variations in herbivore pressure, and then propose a stepwise method to detect deer overabundance and estimate the relative reduction in ungulate pressure to reach sustainable levels. The proposed method integrates vegetation damage scores (0–5 scale) with relative ungulate density estimates based on faecal pellet counts to identify indicator species and assess the sustainability of deer populations. Vegetation surveys were conducted across three Spanish National Parks (Cabañeros, Monfragüe, and Doñana), where deer occur at high densities. Browsing was the only damage that consistently correlated with ungulate pressure, whereas other damages were rare, variable, or weakly related. By integrating frequency, sensitivity, and anticipatory response, we found that plants with medium-high browsing preference were best indicators across parks. Their Pressure–Density Curves, which link ungulate relative density and browsing impact, revealed early and progressive increases in browsing with rising densities. In contrast, highly or non-preferred species were less informative. Using a conservative benchmark (browsing level > 3), beyond which reproductive traits are impaired and plant regeneration is compromised, we found that current relative ungulate densities exceed estimated sustainable levels by 35–44% across the three parks, indicating that substantial population reductions are required to restore vegetation. The use of Pressure–Density curves provide a proactive tool for anticipating ungulate overabundance and informing management decisions. We recommend applying this approach, with appropriate local calibration, through the establishment of permanent monitoring plots and periodic vegetation surveys to guide adaptive management and maintain sustainable ungulate densities.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Carranza et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: