Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
BACKGROUND: Isolated pediatric diaphyseal femur fractures may be treated by a variety of approaches. Studies demonstrate a trend toward more invasive management, outside of AAOS guidelines. We aimed to determine whether treatment choice and outcome were different for those treated by pediatric fellowship-trained surgeons (PF) versus those treated by adult trauma fellowship-trained surgeons (TF). METHODS: We conducted a retrospective review of isolated femoral shaft fractures in patients aged 4 to 14 years treated at two high-volume centers. Exclusion criteria included open fractures, other orthopaedic injuries that affect weight bearing, and same-bone fractures within 1 year. We divided the cohort by treatment choice: spica cast, flexible nails, flexible nails + cast, rigid intramedullary nail, limited exposure bridge plating, and full exposure compression plating. We compared demographics, fracture characteristics, and outcomes, including time to weight bearing, alignment, and additional operations. We included a subanalysis of patients weighing <50 kg. RESULTS: A total of 88 PF-treated and 50 TF-treated patients were identified. The PF cohort was significantly younger (7.2 vs 9.1 years, P < 0.001) and smaller (29.9 vs 41.7 kg, P < 0.00001), with no difference in presenting alignment nor comminution. Treatment choice varied significantly, with more full exposure plating in the TF cohort (68% vs 2.3% in the PF cohort) and more spica casting in the PF cohort (29.5% vs 0% in the TF cohort). At the final follow-up, the PF cohort demonstrated statistically larger angulation (sagittal 5.5° vs 1.0°, P < 0.01; coronal 3.0° vs 0.5°, P < 0.01). Return to OR for revision was rare (1 PF, 0 TF), and there was no difference in time to full weight bearing (32 vs 26 days, P = 0.22). CONCLUSION: Isolated, closed, diaphyseal femur fractures were treated by cast or flexible nails 60% of the time in the PF cohort (<50 kg: 61%) and by full open exposure compression plating or rigid IMN 90% of the time in the TF cohort (<50 kg: 86%) without clinically relevant radiographic outcomes. One PF-treated patient needed revision surgery (1%), with 20% fewer implant removal surgeries compared with those treated by TF-trained surgeons.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ingalls et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: